Scotto’s Pizzeria: Authentic Italian Flavors in Myrtle Beach

We tried the slices and Sicilian style pizza. FYI This is regular oven style pizza, not brick oven. Tasted fine on the slices. The white had no garlic so it was kind of bland. The Sicilian had thicker dough and it was crispier on the bottom than the slices. Maybe from oil or something. I didn’t like the sauce on the Sicilian, but the crispy bottom was a nice change from regular slices. Overall it tasted like pizza does. Nothing special on the toppings. It was decent but nothing I would go back and eat.

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ I went into Scotto's Pizza in Myrtle Beach just wanting a normal chicken parm sandwich… and Anthony said, “Not on my watch.” This man didn’t make a sandwich. He crafted a masterpiece. I’m pretty sure I heard Italian opera playing softly in the background while he layered that crispy chicken like it was the final scene of a cooking show. The sauce? Applied with surgical precision. The cheese? Melted to absolute perfection — not too much, not too little — like he’s been training his whole life for this exact moment. When he handed it to me, I swear it had main-character energy. I took one bite and immediately reconsidered every life choice that led me to eat lesser chicken parms before this one. Anthony doesn’t make sandwiches. He builds edible emotional support systems. 10/10 would let him change my life one chicken parm at a time.

Scottos on a Friday night. A pissed off Uber Eats driver wanting to pick up an order and is told “10 more minutes” and the driver storms out of the place. An elderly guy arguing with the front cashier because he wants a Half this and half that pizza on a small and they say they only do half and half on large so he storms off. I feel like I am back in the Bronx and eat my Scottos special large pie with my family and I am thinking MAN I love this place. Awesome food and a little chaos is a plus!

Overall Score: 7.8/10 – A busy and welcoming local pizza shop with great food, friendly service, and excellent value, making it a strong go-to spot for casual takeout. Atmosphere and Service: 7.6/10 – The restaurant has a classic local pizza shop feel, with a small but fresh and inviting dine-in area. The staff was friendly, and there were plenty of workers to keep things moving even during busy times. The food was ready on time, and the online ordering process was easy and efficient. The menu had all the typical favorites, and the pricing was very reasonable. Cheese Pizza: 7.9/10 – A great pizza overall. Thin, crispy, and cooked perfectly with a satisfying greasy layer from the generous amount of cheese. The sauce tasted great, and the crust was flavorful and well-executed. Excellent value for the quality. Cheesesteak: 6.7/10 – A strong option, especially for the price. It was packed with plenty of steak, and the bread was fresh and tasty. It could have used a little more cheese and onions to better balance the generous amount of meat, but it was still a very good sandwich with great value.

Great place for slices, will be hitting this up again for sure! The NY was paper thin, had nice doneness underneath, minimal flop, good bite, & nice crispy crunch. The White slice mirrors the NY slice just slightly thicker.

Awesome food. Wish they had fresh tea and not fountain. Second time here. Love the food. Everyone was very friendly. Will definitely be back when I'm in the area

Best pizza I've had so far.... I got the Sicilian style with pepperoni.. Delicious sauce also! The chicken roll they make is huge! And I bought the small one!

Best pizza in Myrtle beach!! It was so good we had it 2 nights in a row. And will probably eat it again tomorrow! This is a hidden gem! I’m so glad we found it!